What Are Certified Pre-Owned Cars and Why You Should Avoid Them

Cautious car buyers often choose certified pre-owned vehicles to ease their worries about purchasing a used car with an unknown history. These “cherry-picked” vehicles are newer models with low mileage that are held to high standards. Dealerships or manufacturers will put the cars through multi-point inspections, check hundreds of parts, and back them with extended warranties before the certification. Certified pre-owned vehicles therefore give consumers a peace of mind that regular used cars can’t, but there are actually some hidden downsides to this option to be aware of.

Premium Prices

Car dealers cash in on selling “certified pre-owned” vehicles as people are willing to blindly pay higher prices. Basically, it is a marketing scheme. The label allows them to jack up prices when compared to non-certified counterparts with similar mileage. A like-new certified car can have an additional cost of $850 to $3000. Some buyers are willing to pay the premium price for the “CPO” label but it is just for a false sense of comfort.

Inspection Fails

The intensive inspections these choice vehicles undergo for a dealership’s certified pre-owned sticker is often no more rigorous than the average used car inspection or reconditioning process. Sometimes there are hidden damages or issues overlooked that will be revealed down the road. Even though a certified pre-owned vehicle has a label backing it up, it is no different than any other used car. Buyers just pay more to know information that the dealers already have such as major collisions or defects. And most importantly, only the car’s manufacturer can certify a vehicle based on their specific inspection criteria.

Manufacturer or Third Party Certification?

There is a major difference between a certification from the manufacturer or one handed out by the dealership. Only the manufacturer’s franchised dealers can truly certify and sell a CPO vehicle. For example, only a Toyota dealer can certify a Toyota. If a Ford dealership is trying to sell a Toyota as certified, it is a made-up dealership certification, not a true manufacturer’s certification. A real certification will come with certain perks such as roadside assistance and the factory extended warranty.

Warranty Misconceptions

The major perk to buying a certified pre-owned vehicle is the extended warranty. It grants the peace of mind if anything were to go wrong with the vehicle, you could have coverage. Certified pre-owned vehicles may come with a few different warranty structures such as a limited warranty with powertrain or an extended factory warranty. It is wise to investigate all the details and check on the automaker’s website before assuming what is covered. Sometimes you might be paying extra for things that are already covered for the car without the certification.

In a recent study, Consumer Reports revealed that the cost savings you get when purchasing an extended warranty vs a certified pre owned car is staggering. An extended warranty that is bumper to bumper will cover almost twice as much as a certified pre-owned warranty and is usually less than half the price of a certified pre owned warranty.

Compare Cars

Certified pre-owned cars can give people a false optimism when it comes to certain guarantees about their purchase.  In reality, a used car will never be pristine again and dealers are trying to cash in on consumer insecurities. Although buying a vehicle that is a couple years old or lightly used can save you a ton of cash versus buying brand new; paying extra for a CPO label is not all it’s made out to be. Certified pre-owned vehicles sound great to begin with, but buyers are better off saving the money and checking out regular used cars. It is important to do research, compare multiple cars from different sources, and be willing to negotiate topics like the details of warranty terms.

Ready to Sell Your Vehicle?

We Buy All Cars in NJ is New Jersey’s largest independent car buying agency and provides ABOVE market quotes without the selling fees unlike our competitors.  Call our owner Jason directly at (856) 834-5558 to get your free quote or fill out the form in our sidebar.



“No hassle and easy…had check quickly and I was on my way to the bank.”-Oliver Cruz1star1star1star1star1star

“We found them to be not only fair but very knowledgeable. I will use this service again in the future.”-Judy B.1star1star1star1star1star

Read More Testimonials

Don't Trade It
We Will Buy It

Whether it's worth
$100 or $100,000

"We want your used car"

We Buy All Cars In NJ

701 Cooper Road, Suite #10,
Voorhees, New Jersey, 08043
p: (856) 834-5558
e: [email protected]

What Kind Of Paperwork Do You Need To Sell Your Vehicle?

What Kind Of Paperwork Do You Need To Sell Your Vehicle?

What Kind Of Paperwork Do You Need To Sell Your Vehicle? When you are ready or in the market to trade in your vehicle for a new set of wheels, you want to make sure you have all the necessary paperwork in order to ensure a smooth transaction.  Having the necessary...

How to Maintain Your Car’s Value

How to Maintain Your Car's Value Most people are only concerned with their used car value when it is time to trade it in or sell it. However, taking simple steps to care for your car on a regular basis will get you the maximum amount of money when it is time for a new...

Make New Year’s Resolutions for Your Car

Making New Year’s Resolutions is as much a holiday tradition as Santa Claus or getting soused on New Year’s Eve. The most common resolutions are predictable – lose weight, pay off debt, or get a better job. How do your car plans figure into your resolutions though?...

Are Holiday Car Sales Worth It?

Are Holiday Car Sales Really Worth it? Holiday car sales get a lot of hype. If you open up any newspaper or turn on the television, the advertisements are everywhere. The holidays are expensive enough though, so before you head out to the car lot, seriously consider...

How to Take Advantage of Holiday Car Deals

The Best Holiday to Buy a Car If you’re looking to save the maximum amount of money on a new or used car, the best time to buy is the week between Christmas and New Year. Car dealers are looking to move leftover models, and to meet their end-of-year sales goals. The...