Selling Your Used Car After An Accident

The dismal truth is that car accidents happen a lot in the United States. Car accidents across the country cost the U.S. $230.6 billion per year - an average of $820 per person! Another unhappy fact is that New Jersey drivers don’t have the best reputation. A 2012 Forbes article called NJ “home to the second worst drivers in the country”. According to the State of New Jersey Department of Transportation, there were 265,540 car accidents on NJ roads in 2014.


If you’re in the unfortunate position of having just experienced a car accident, your insurance company will start off the process by doing two things:

  • Assess the amount of damage to your car (some might give a repair estimate)
  • Tell you what your car was worth before the accident. This assessment is based on the year, make, model, mileage, and most recent prices for similar cars. If the cost of repairing the vehicle ends up being more than the car itself is worth, the insurance company will declare it a “total loss”.

Your insurance company may or may not want to fix your damaged car. If they decide to pass on repairing it, they may give you a check for the replacement value calculated on the basis of its pre-accident condition. Once the claim is settled, two solutions are possible - the insurance company will keep the damaged vehicle or they will let you keep it.

Can I Sell My Car if It’s Been in an Accident?

Yes! If you’ve been in a car accident and you find yourself in possession of a damaged vehicle and decide you want to sell it, you can do it quickly and easily through We Buy All Cars. We’ll buy cars in any condition - whether you’ve been in a minor fender-bender or your car is completely totaled.

How Do I Know if My Car is Totaled?

The term “totaled” is pretty straightforward and comes from the insurance term “total loss”. Your car is totaled if you've been in an accident and the car isn't repairable or it costs more to repair it than what the vehicle is actually worth. What isn’t so straightforward is the value of your car after it has been totaled in an accident because it varies greatly from car to car.

It’s important to understand that damage to your car can affect the value depending on the severity of the damage. The silver lining is that We Buy All Cars In NJ will still buy your car for Above Market value even if its been in a minor or serious accident. To get a quick and accurate quote on your vehicle, fill out our form in the sidebar or give us a call at (856) 834-5558 and a representative will be happy to further assist you.

What is a Salvage Car?

A car is typically deemed “salvage” when it has been damaged in some way, like through an auto accident. An owner might determine that the car will cost more to fix than what it’s worth. Depending on what you want to do next, New Jersey has a set of salvage regulations that must be followed in order to get the car back on the road in a legal and safe way or to log the vehicle as unusable:

  • Contact your local Motor Vehicle Commission office and disclose the state of your car. The MVC will issue a salvage title, which means a vehicle can’t be registered regularly after that point. A salvage title, or salvage certificate, is administered in place of your old car title. When your car is totaled or salvaged, you’ll need the salvage title/certificate to sell it.
  • If you repair a salvage vehicle and want to put it back on the road, the state will first conduct a vehicle identification number (VIN) inspection to make sure none of the component parts (or the car itself) were stolen.
  • Repairing and retitling a salvage vehicle can be difficult, with a lot of paperwork involved, so be sure to keep all documents showing where you bought the parts you used to resuscitate the vehicle.

After an accident, your insurance company will deduct a “salvage value” (the estimated value of your car) from your claim settlement. The good news after so much stressful business is that you can make a profit higher than the salvage value deduction when you sell the damaged car to We Buy All Cars!

How Do I Apply for Salvage Title?

To apply for a salvage title in New Jersey, visit your local MVC office, but be sure to call ahead to make sure your office of choice processes salvage titles, and bring the following documentation:

  • The certificate of title assigned to your insurance company
  • Payment for the $60 title fee and $25 penalty fee, if applicable
  • A completed insurance listing sheet (Form BA-28 on the MVC website)

In most circumstances, buyers and dealerships don’t want a car with a salvage title because the damage is too extreme, but at We Buy All Cars In NJ, that’s not an issue. We’re interested in all types of used cars regardless of whether or not the car has been in an accident and/or has a salvage title.

How Do I Understand the Damage to My Car After an Accident?

The easiest way to get a summary of a car’s backstory is to reference the vehicle history report, which shows accidents and damages across the vehicle’s lifespan. For a free CarFax report, call us at (856) 834-5558 and have your VIN number handy.


“No hassle and easy…had check quickly and I was on my way to the bank.”-Oliver Cruz1star1star1star1star1star

“We found them to be not only fair but very knowledgeable. I will use this service again in the future.”-Judy B.1star1star1star1star1star

Read More Testimonials

Don't Trade It
We Will Buy It

Whether it's worth
$100 or $100,000

"We want your used car"

We Buy All Cars In NJ

701 Cooper Road, Suite #10,
Voorhees, New Jersey, 08043
p: (856) 834-5558
e: [email protected]

What Kind Of Paperwork Do You Need To Sell Your Vehicle?

What Kind Of Paperwork Do You Need To Sell Your Vehicle?

What Kind Of Paperwork Do You Need To Sell Your Vehicle? When you are ready or in the market to trade in your vehicle for a new set of wheels, you want to make sure you have all the necessary paperwork in order to ensure a smooth transaction.  Having the necessary...

How to Maintain Your Car’s Value

How to Maintain Your Car's Value Most people are only concerned with their used car value when it is time to trade it in or sell it. However, taking simple steps to care for your car on a regular basis will get you the maximum amount of money when it is time for a new...

Make New Year’s Resolutions for Your Car

Making New Year’s Resolutions is as much a holiday tradition as Santa Claus or getting soused on New Year’s Eve. The most common resolutions are predictable – lose weight, pay off debt, or get a better job. How do your car plans figure into your resolutions though?...

Are Holiday Car Sales Worth It?

Are Holiday Car Sales Really Worth it? Holiday car sales get a lot of hype. If you open up any newspaper or turn on the television, the advertisements are everywhere. The holidays are expensive enough though, so before you head out to the car lot, seriously consider...

How to Take Advantage of Holiday Car Deals

The Best Holiday to Buy a Car If you’re looking to save the maximum amount of money on a new or used car, the best time to buy is the week between Christmas and New Year. Car dealers are looking to move leftover models, and to meet their end-of-year sales goals. The...